In the Bleak Midwinter

Winner of Carol’s Best Christmas Music – Category: Mellow
The Gift by Liz Story
Windham Hill.
Solo piano.
Recommended first by sister Dorothy.
New to me this year.

(This post is from the archives.)

One of my favorites is In the Bleak Midwinter, a piece that James Taylor also does very well.

I know you are very, very busy.  You should be wrapping gifts instead of reading blogs.

May I tell you a story?  Why this song means so very much to me?

It is a family story that I only know from the telling, because, sadly, I was not present.  Twenty-one years ago, my father received a diagnosis of pancreatic cancer from Mayo Clinic on Christmas Eve.  The following weekend, those of my siblings who could, gathered at my dad’s place in Dubuque. That Sunday Dan sang  In The Bleak Midwinter at the chapel.  A Capella.  He’s a professional, my brother.  But when he came to the last verse, (What shall I bring him, poor as I am?) he broke down and wept.  Unable to continue. My father walked up to him, put his arms around him, and held him.  No words.

So this piece, which has a mournful tone already (and that is not a criticism), always  takes me to that Sunday, to a sad family, a very brave brother, and a father who was a father in a most public act of comforting his son; to my Father who gave His Son, to his mother who worshiped him with a kiss, and mostly to the poverty of the writer who offers what she can give–her heart.

In the Bleak Midwinter.

Snippet of James Taylor singing it (scroll down).
30 seconds of Liz Story playing it.
Better yet, Glouster Cathedral Choir singing it:


17 thoughts on “In the Bleak Midwinter

  1. How dear!
    A personal favorite of mine as well since it is the first carol my four daughters learned to sing as a quartet, when they were 12, 10, 9, and 7.
    Another one that tears me up every time…It is Well with My Soul.
    These really are good memories ๐Ÿ™‚

  2. Your story brought tears to me eyes. I love this carol. Always have. I really miss my time to read and comment on my favorite girls’ blogs. Things are going well here, just very, very busy. Sometimes I think my head will burst!Blessed Christmas, Carol!Janie

  3. That Gloucester Cathedral clip is in my faves youtube folder. undoes me every time… what a glorious story. just home from a massive roadtrip to South Carolina – will be blogging tonight, i hope. It’s also chaotic blizzard central here so we’ve got to batten down the hatches. When we left it was WARM and SUNNY! A late winter arrival here in the Boo.Love you. Miss you. Just…. someday.

  4. I purchased the Liz Story album last Christmas, thanks to your recommendation—and I love it! What a touching connection you have with the Bleak Midwinter song. So amazing how music can be both sad and healing at the same time. Blessings of the season to you, Carol.

  5. Thanks for posting this and my, does it bring back memories.  This is still my favorite Christmas Carol — made more sweet by what happened those 21 years ago.  One small addition.  When it became obvious that I couldn’t continue, Dad (who was preaching that day) did come and put his arms around me but then he recited the last verse which was a wonderful completion.  Danny

  6. An excellent video of a wonderful carol.  Many thanks :)To save me going to another post about lyric confusion, you may know the children’s chorus by Philip Bliss:Dare to be a Daniel,Dare to stand alone!Dare to have a purpose fine!Dare to make it known.My dear mother thought the third line was “Dare to have a purple spine” and wondered why that would be a noble ambition….

Comments are cinnamon on my oatmeal!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s