My Boy Jack

Last night my men put a moratorium on sad (WWI) war movies.  Ain’t gonna study war no more!

In the all-or-nothing mentality that marinates in the marrow of all those born with my maiden name, I have had my guys watch a dozen movies on the Great War with me.  (psst – don’t mention it, but there are seven more in my queue – there is a delete button, I guess)  This 2007 BBC movie of a screen play written by David Haig is a top notch movie that will surely make you cry.  There is not a happy ending, my friend.

Daniel Radcliffe plays young John “Jack” Kipling, a young man whose desire to go to war is thwarted by his extreme nearsightedness.  His father uses his influence to get Jack into the Irish Guards. 

The arc of this movie about Rudyard Kipling and his family is similar to the arc in the story of C.S. Lewis in Shadowlands.  A strong speaker with large audiences makes bold, booming declarative statements.  Life intervenes; by the end of story you see a profoundly changed man struggling with his private grief. 

David Haig, who wrote the screenplay and played Kipling, looks uncannily like Rudyard Kipling.  Part of the movie was filmed at Bateman’s, Kiplings estate in Sussex.

I need to learn more about Kipling.  He’s considered controversial these days, especially his poem “The White Man’s Burden.”  His astonishing ability to tell stories is framed well in this movie.  But he was indubitably an British imperialist, a man of his time.  Here is his poem, My Boy Jack

My Boy Jack

“HAVE you news of my boy Jack?”
    Not this tide.
“When d’you think that he’ll come back?”
    Not with this wind blowing, and this tide.

“Has any one else had word of him?”
    Not this tide.
For what is sunk will hardly swim,
    Not with this wind blowing, and this tide.

“Oh, dear, what comfort can I find?”
    None this tide,
    Nor any tide,
Except he did not shame his kind—
    Not even with that wind blowing, and that tide.

Then hold your head up all the more,
    This tide,
    And every tide;
Because he was the son you bore,
    And gave to that wind blowing and that tide!


6 thoughts on “My Boy Jack

  1. I’ve had this in my queue for a while, but I know it’s sad, so I keep skipping over it. Kevin is a WWII buff, and has said he would like to know more about WWI. I wish Ken Burns would make a documentary on it like he did with WWII. It seems much more complicated to understand the roots of the 1st World War.Carrie

  2. I watched this when it first came out on PBS. As usual I was not disappointed. Extremely tender and well done, the culture of the time seemed to be portrayed well, the attitudes of those young British men so eagar to go and do their duty, the gung ho’dness’ of their country. I did have to wipe a tear or two away as it was so sad, even though I knew the outcome, and I didn’t think the sadness was limited Jack’s death, the anguish his family felt and the changes Rudyard went through dealing with his guilt and understanding how truly terrible war is, nothing glorious is in it at all, it was all so tenderly done and I’m a crier any way! It’s nice to see both these actors out of their ‘normal’ areas and see what fine jobs they can do in completely different subject matters.

  3. @nnjmom – Carrie, I would recommend PBS’ The Great War which I believe is only out on VHS.  We had it at our library.  It has a Burns-ish feel to it. @applechexx – you said it well – tender.  Kipling’s character drew out all sorts of emotion in me: admiration, exasperation, frustration, etc.  At times I wanted to slap him, but by the end I just wanted to hug him.  So very sad.

  4. Carol,Do you know if the movie screenplay was written off the Young Adult book, Kipling’s Choice by Geert Spillebeen (Translated by Terese Edelstein)?  I read that a couple of years ago and enjoyed it.  Sherry

  5. @Sherry – Sherry, I don’t know but the book sounds very much like the plot line of the movie.  One snippet I read – somewhere – indicated that the play and movie have been in the works for 22 years.  It looks like the book was published in 2005.  I guess David Haig, the writer and actor who played Kipling, was given a biography of Kipling many years ago.  He said it was like looking into the mirror (they could pass for twins) and stimulated his growing interest in Rudyard Kipling.@Jbbs_Musings – Thanks for the link!

Comments are cinnamon on my oatmeal!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s