I tried one of those last night. Not biology, but an experiment reading to a toddler from my Kindle. All the time I had Dan Newman’s quote, “Maybe I’m a Luddite because I feel sorry for children who read “Goodnight Moon” on a phone.” in my head. Knowing this would fail, I asked my 2 1/2 year old grandson, Noah, if I could read him a book. Reading is a daily delight in his life and he readily acquiesced.
I picked up my Kindle, slid the power on, and pressed buttons. Thanks to Janet, I had Thornton Burgess’s Bird Book for Children on my Kindle. We started with Jenny Wren Arrives. Happily the first character is Peter Rabbit. Yay for familiarity! But Noah is a mimic and if Nana pushed buttons, he wanted to push buttons too. A book with buttons that he wasn’t allowed to push, pull, tap, or pound just made no sense.
The next hurdle was the lack of pictures. In order to compensate for the visual wasteland, I tried to capitalize on the oral/aural parts. I had Noah repeat “tut, tut, tut, tut, tut”; I gave “Jenny Wren” a Southern drawl, and had him say “JAY-nee RAY-in” after me each time the name came up. This morning when Noah woke, we continued the tuts and JennyWren’s.
But we only made it through four Kindle pages before I surrendered. Noah’s mom said she saw glimpses of cheerful panic in his eyes. We replaced the Kindle with picture books and all was well, again.
I could envision this working in perhaps four years with a bird coloring book and crayons.
Reading to a toddler with a Kindle. Fail! But I’d like to believe it wasn’t an epic fail.
He’s adorable!Too bad the Kindle-reading didn’t work out, but I love that you gave Jenny Wren a Southern accent! Wish I’d thought of that… My 7-year-old is okay with the Kindle, but it’s because she’s able to follow along now — especially if I make the font larger. I doubt she would have done well with it at 3 either.
Noah had obviously read the quote from GK Chesterton on here not long ago:”Don’t believe in anything that can’t be told in colored pictures.”:)