Cahill, Again

Thomas Cahill is on a mission.  In his series, The Hinges of History, he is telling the story of Western Civilization in the context of gift giving. 

But history is also the narratives of grace, the recountings of those
blessed and inexplicable moments when someone did something    
for someone else, saved a life, bestowed a gift, gave something     
beyond what was required by circumstance.                                   

After his books on the Irish, the Jews, Jesus of Nazareth, and the Greeks, Cahill turns to medieval history.  He focuses on the story and influence of a few people:  Hildegard of Bingen, Eleanor of Aquitaine, Francis of Assisi, Abelard and Héloïse, Thomas Aquinas, Chaucer, Giotto and Dante.  

Cahill’s Mysteries is very accessible, an easy to read book classified as pop history.  Without becoming too facile, he employs non-academic words, current idioms, and recent events in his writing: calling the Franciscans the first hippies, comparing earlier Islamic-Christian conflicts with the 9-11 attack by bin Laden and the war on Iraq. 

To name a child Astralabe [speaking Abelard and Héloïse’s love child]     
was to suggest that he was destined to be a very modern (and starry)       
trendsetter. It brings to mind the avant-garde rock musician Frank Zappa,
who named his daughter Moon Unit.
                                                         

The book contains many rich, colorful illustrations and photographs, especially of the art he reviews.  His style of footnoting is my absolute favorite: on the same page on a side column in a slightly smaller font.

The biggest blunder of this book is its title.  There are no cults in the book and the mysteries invoked in the title are intended to denote a sacramental wonder.  The subtitle doesn’t work at all.  At the end of the book Cahill looks at the current state of the (Roman) Catholic church.  I sense that a love for the (his?) church is the motivation for pages of text on the current priestly pedophilia crisis.  He argues for optional celibacy (married clergy, I think) and popular election of clerical positions which are now appointed.

I don’t think Cahill has ever matched the quality of work he did in How the Irish Saved Civilization.  I am grateful to have read Mysteries for two particular reasons:  His resounding recommendation of Kristin Lavransdatter; and his last two chapters on Dante which have primed my pump for reading The Divine Comedy

But I am thankful that I didn’t buy this book.  One read through was enough.

                        

4 thoughts on “Cahill, Again

  1. Carol – I’m teaching the Middle Ages to my kids this year using Story of the World, Volume II, and I was looking for a good book for myself to supplement. Would you suggest this one? Or is there something else that would be better? I can’t read history books that are dry – I love Ambrose, McCullough – that style.
    Any suggestions would be appreciated!
    Carrie

  2. Hmmmm, let me think a little on this one. As far as readability Cahill probably wins hands down. One reviewer called him more impressionistic than expository.Sherry over at Semicolon recommended A Distant Mirror as one of the best books on Medieval times. It focuses on one family, but its a long one. I may not get to it this summer, although it’s on my shelf waiting patiently.Actually, Carrie, the very easiest book to read would be the Kristin Lavransdatter trilogy. Go to the link in this post and read what Cahill said about it.”There is no single work that gives one a more intense and extensive understanding of the Middle Ages.” You would really enjoy this, I promise it. I would love to give KL to every teenage girl I know. Even though it is fiction, it is historically accurate. Undset won a Nobel Peace Prize. That’s what I’d recommend: Kristin. I’m in the middle of the second book and I’m wearing out my highlighter.

  3. I also highly recommend a series of four books by Thomas Costain, nonfiction history of England during the Middle Ages. The first book is called The Conquering Family. Costain emphasizes the royals and personalities, but it’s very readable and enjoyable. The other three books are The Three Edwards, The Magnificent Century and The Last Plantaganets. One of the books covers the same time period as A Distant Mirror, but DM takes place mostly in France while the Costain books are definitely Anglo-centric. Oh, and Kristin is wonderful.

Comments are cinnamon on my oatmeal!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s